Trustees Seek Input on Sidewalk Shoveling Ordinance

Woodstock Village Trustees want your input on the subject of  a required sidewalk snow shoveling ordinance, which has annually  stirred some controversy and was an agenda item at Tuesday night’s meeting,

For years, village residents have been required to clear their own sidewalks in the winter, or face a fine for not doing so. Some residents, however, have objected to this, saying it is unfair that those who are physically unable to do such work have to pay someone to get the job done.

Some who attended last night’s meeting  want to see the village take on the job. Others , including some Trustees, object to adding this expense to their taxes.

Village  Manager Phil Swanson said last night that an estimate from 7 or 8 years ago put the estimate at $140,000 per year as what would be required for  the Village to clear the sidewalks. However, Village Trustee Bob Pear calculates that buying an appropriate snow-cat type blower and hiring a seasonal employee for this work, for six months  in the winter to cover the six miles of sidewalk  would only cost the Village $25,000.

Commenting on the estimated $140,000 sum, Village Trustee Patricia Compton said, “That’s an enormous figure to add to our taxes.”

At last night’s  Trustees meeting, High Street resident Annie MacDonald said she preferred to have the Village do this work.
“I’d be $300 richer, and I’d be very happy if my taxes were more” to pay for the work, MacDonald said. She also wanted the snow clearing to be more consistent throughout the village. Due to economic hardship and a bad back, and her husband having to be off to work early some mornings, she is not able to clear her sidewalk and has been subject to fines in the past. She also asked  why she might end up legally responsible  for someone getting hurt on it due to inadequate clearing when it’s a Village walkway.

For Village Trustee Bob Pear, it’s  safety issue for pedestrians. “There are areas at times where you have to walk out into the street. That’s unsafe. Sometimes the sidewalk is left icy. That’s unsafe,” Pear said.
The Trustees are  considering  letting Village resident  decide whether the municipality should pay for sidewalk snow removal. They  could put this snow removal  matter on the 2012 Village Meeting ballot themselves, or concerned citizens could bring forward a petition with at least 40 signatures to force a 2012 vote.

For now, the Village Trustees will re-visit the snow issue at a December meeting. They say they want time to hear from more people on either side of the issue before making any move to change the ordinance. 

Note:  Woodstock Early Bird spoke on this issue as a resident of the Village and said she supports Village removal of sidewalk snow in a consistent manner saying it goes to the issue of how we present ourselves overall to the visiting public and as a way to provide consistently cleared and safer sidewalks throughout the Village.  We also believe that an ordinance which slaps fines on those least able to pay for contracted snow shovelers or those least physically able to do the work themselves  is discriminatory.  At the very least, maybe we need to put some of our Irene Flood Response volunteerism into action to help those who need a little help this winter to stay in compliance with Village ordinance.

5 responses to this post.

  1. Andrea Sand's avatar

    Posted by Andrea Sand on November 9, 2011 at 14:41

    What I especially love is when our snow-blower guy clears off the sidewalk (for quite a chunk of $$$$) and then the town truck comes by and pushes snow all over it — and I have to go out and clear it by hand with a shovel.

    Like

  2. Donna's avatar

    Posted by Donna on November 9, 2011 at 17:39

    I bet there are plenty of people who would do the job for 1/3 of that $140,000 bid.

    I know at my house,you no more than get things cleaned up, then the plow comes thru, it can be a never ending job.

    I am with Bob Pear, buy a blower and hire someone to do it.

    Like

  3. Pat Crocker's avatar

    Posted by Pat Crocker on November 9, 2011 at 18:16

    Exactly my thoughts Andrea. The “sidewalk” is virtually on the street in many village neighborhoods, while some neighborhoods have no sidewalks at all! The rule used to be to have cleared a path; now it must be clear to dry pavement and that is a standard that is VERY difficult to meet.

    After nearly 30 years of shoveling/blowing our own snow, we have hired someone to do the job this winter for many of the same reasons cited by others…we are not physically able to handle it anymore.

    The sidewalks are for the use of all the public. As a shared resource they should be a shared responsibility. Rather than looking at the aggregate total, maybe we could look at the cost per capita or per property. For many of us it might look like a bargain compared to what we individually pay now.

    If the cost of capital investment in equipment is an issue, then we could put a contract for the service out to bid and see whether that would cost less. And, for some, the additional tax is deductible.

    Like

  4. lina's avatar

    Here! Here!
    We are in agreement with the invest in a village sidewalk plow.
    We are the only house on Maple Street that has sidewalk. When we were in bank negotiations to buy this house and when we were renovating, living elsewhere and fighting’ cancer we got our share of warnings and tickets. They come and plow the little bridge over Kedron to Vale, it doesn’t seem like much to do 40 feet more of the walking loop.
    Invest invest then the street plow and the sidewalk plow can snow bank battle each other!

    Like

  5. Bob Pear's avatar

    Posted by Bob Pear on November 16, 2011 at 20:16

    There is one inaccuracy in the article, “For years, village residents have been required to clear their own sidewalks in the winter, or face a fine for not doing so”. The sidewalks are not owned by the individual property owners, but are property of the municipality, or public- the community. The municipality is requiring “the abutting property owners” to clear the public sidewalks as stated in our village ordinance. It does not require “non-abutters” to share in this civic duty or responsibility to our community.

    Like

Comments are closed.